Collisions could increase chance of 'God of Destruction' asteroid Apophis hitting Earth

A blue, green and white sphere is approached by an elongated grey and purple rock with a smoky tail
An illustration shows the God of Destruction asteroid Apophis approaching Earth (Image credit: Robert Lea (created with Canva)/NASA/The Planetary Society)

On Friday, 13, 2029, Earth will have a fascinating and intimidating visitor in the form of the "God of Destruction" asteroid Apophis. The asteroid — named after the Egyptian serpent god of chaos and destruction Apep — is so large and will pass within 19,000 miles (30,600 kilometers) of Earth, so close to our planet that it could be visible to the naked eye. 

New research has suggested that if other much smaller space rocks hit Apophis, the asteroid, which is almost as wide as the Empire State Building is tall, could be redirected, and Earth might not be narrowly missed by it during subsequent passages or in extreme circumstances, even during the 2029 passage. But don't panic just yet. 

Research author Paul Wiegert, an astronomer at the University of Western Ontario, told Space.com that the odds of a dangerous asteroid strike on Apophis are very low. "The odds are essentially 1 in a million that an asteroid strike could deflect Apophis enough to put it in danger of a future post-2029 collision, and only 1 in a billion that it could send Apophis colliding with Earth in 2029," he said.

"I calculated the odds of asteroid Apophis, whose current path is computed to take it near but safely past our planet in 2029, being deflected onto a more dangerous path by an unexpected small asteroid impact," Wiegert explained. "These are the same kind of small asteroids that occasionally appear in our atmosphere as 'shooting stars' or 'fireballs' and could strike Apophis just as unexpectedly."

Related: 'God of Destruction' asteroid Apophis will come to Earth in 2029 — and it could meet some tiny spacecraft

Wiegert explained that in the research, he questioned whether an asteroid would strike during the period from 2021 to 2027 when our telescopes couldn't observe Apophis and if this could deflect it enough to make it dangerous. 

"Asteroid Apophis is essentially unobservable from now until 2027 because it is in the daytime sky, and so it could be hit without us being immediately aware of the event," he continued.

A chaotic event could mean the rise of Apophis

Discovered in 2004, Apophis (full designation Apophis 99942) immediately rose to the top of tables that measure the risk of so-called potentially hazardous asteroids (PHAs) asteroids with widths of 460 feet (140 meters) or more that come within 20 lunar distances of Earth. 

Both the size of Apophis and its trajectory saw it remain at the top of both the European Space Agency's (ESA's) "impact risk list" of PHAs and NASA's Sentry Risk Table for almost two decades.

That was until a close flyby of the asteroid in March 2021 allowed NASA scientists to determine Apophis actually won't hit the Earth for at least 100 years. 

Now, this new research shows that chance encounters with other space rocks could redirect the 1,000-foot-wide (305-meter-wide)  Apophis to put it on a collision course with Earth in 2029 or later, meaning it could rocket back to the top of the risk tables. 

Wiegart calculated the effect that objects of different sizes would have if they struck Apophis and then used the number of objects of these sizes that strike Earth each year to determine the probability of such an impact.

"An asteroid about 60 centimeters (24 inches) across could, if it struck Apophis from exactly the right direction, put Apophis onto a post-2029 collision course. But it would take a 3 meter (10 foot) diameter asteroid to strike Apophis, again, in just the right direction, to put in danger of a collision in 2029," Wiegart said. "These kinds of collisions are extremely rare."

When considering the angle necessary to divert Apophis so that it could strike Earth on a future passage, Wiegart found the chance of the asteroid being diverted to hit our planet after 2029 to be 1 in 1 million. The chances of a roughly 3-meter-wide asteroid hitting Apophis and putting it on a collision course with Earth in 2029 were  1 in 2 billion.

An illustration of NASA's Double Asteroid Redirection Test, or DART, as it approaches its target. Could such measures be deployed against Apophis? (Image credit: NASA/Johns Hopkins APL)

These low odds are fortunate considering the huge damage Apophis would cause were it to strike Earth. The Planetary Society estimated that if Apophis were to hit Earth it could release energy equal to more than 1,000 megatons of TNT, equivalent to the detonation of tens or even hundreds of nuclear weapons.

This could spread devastation across a radius of hundreds of miles. Even though it won't come close to the devastation caused 65,000,000 years ago by the asteroid that wiped out the dinosaurs and two-thirds of all species on Earth, millions of people would die if Apophis hit a highly populated metropolitan area.

If we discover Apophis is on a collision course with Earth during its next passages in 2029, 2036, and 2068, we would have some options to attempt to divert it. For instance, just as a small impact could shift the God of Destruction space rock toward Earth, another small collision could reorientate its trajectory away again if space agencies had enough warning.

In 2022, NASA tried out this idea, striking the asteroid system Dimorphos and Didymos with the Double Asteroid Redirection Test (DART) impactor and measuring the change in its motion.

"It is possible that a mission like DART could be used to divert Apophis back onto a safe path, but exactly how and if this would work has yet to be worked out," Wiegart said. 

Other diversions range from the forceful, such as hitting an asteroid with a nuclear weapon, to the sublime, such as painting one side of an asteroid black, causing it to absorb more solar radiation, shifting its center of mass, and altering its trajectory. These methods are well-founded scientifically but are yet to be tested.

"It's difficult to say what other diversion methods would work, but scientists are thinking hard about our options," Wiegart said.

Though Apophis is unlikely to live up to its fearsome name in 2029 by impacting Earth, its scientific impact will be immeasurable. Plans are already being hatched to use spacecraft and satellites to rendezvous with the asteroid as it heads toward its closest approach to our planet.

"Apophis' upcoming close pass in 2029 is a natural milestone for our planet, as we move into a time where we as a global community have the ability to avoid disastrous asteroid impacts like those that may have extinguished the dinosaurs," Wiegart concluded. "The astronomical community as a whole is continuing to think about dangerous asteroids like Apophis as well as possible next steps."

Wiegart's Apophis research was published in The Planetary Science Journal.

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com.

Robert Lea
Senior Writer

Robert Lea is a science journalist in the U.K. whose articles have been published in Physics World, New Scientist, Astronomy Magazine, All About Space, Newsweek and ZME Science. He also writes about science communication for Elsevier and the European Journal of Physics. Rob holds a bachelor of science degree in physics and astronomy from the U.K.’s Open University. Follow him on Twitter @sciencef1rst.

  • absorbingphotons
    At best, this article is clickbait. At its worst, this article is bad journalism.

    Writing a headline like that when you know well that NASA has already stated there is 0% chance of Apophis hitting Earth for the next 100 years. You all should be ashamed of yourselves...

    Stop sensationalizing Apophis just for clicks & ad revenue. Greed on its finest display.
    Reply
  • Classical Motion
    After looking at the moon, I wouldn't give any rock out there a 0% chance.
    Reply
  • absorbingphotons
    Eh, NASA still said 0%. I think I'll trust NASA over some random stranger on the internet who has an opinion.

    "Now, the results from a new radar observation campaign combined with precise orbit analysis have helped astronomers conclude that there is no risk of Apophis impacting our planet for at least a century."

    https://www.nasa.gov/solar-system/nasa-analysis-earth-is-safe-from-asteroid-apophis-for-100-plus-years/
    Reply
  • Classical Motion
    I’ve always been an oddball. Even if I had a catalog with all the rocks and moving positions for the last hundred years, I would not give any rock a 0% chance of collision with earth.

    And I don’t believe in probability. But I do believe in unknown happenstance.

    The center of our MW could have super nova-ed 23 k years ago and we not know it. Not even the shine has got here. One of out neighbors could have done so years ago and might hit us until tomorrow.

    The only warning is arrival. Just a shine shock could plummet us with our rocks.
    Reply
  • Pogo
    And any strike by another object has a greater chance of causing Apophis to move farther away from Earth as toward it.
    Reply
  • Unclear Engineer
    I look at this article as a good example of thinking about the incompleteness of most of our probability modeling.

    Clearly, just like we hope to be able to defend our planet by striking an asteroid with a spacecraft impactor to deflect it enough, early enough, for it to be made to miss Earth, there is an opposite side to the same physical concept - a natural object collision with an asteroid could make a miss turn into a hit on Earth.

    Looking at it as carefully as we know how, including what sized objects could move Apophis' path 19,000 miles towards Earth by 2029, how many such objects are in the area of its orbit, and what the probability is for such an impact to move the orbit to the "wrong" path instead of a "better" path, seems like good scientific thinking to me. It helps us gauge the reliability of the projected path and prediction that we are "safe" (from this one) for 100 years or more.
    Reply
  • Classical Motion
    From what we know, we think only our home brew rocks have impacted. Who’s to know if external system debris could enter. Or might have in the past. And what kind of warning we might get.

    What would it be like to pass thru a galactic debris field.

    If 100,000(probably many more) foreign rocks entered our system and would assume at high velocity, would we even have time to calculate probability? What could we really do but watch.
    Reply
  • rod
    I note this report I read yesterday. Earth may have had a ring system 466 million years ago, https://phys.org/news/2024-09-earth-million-years.html, ref - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012821X24004230?via%3Dihub
    "In a discovery that challenges our understanding of Earth's ancient history, researchers have found evidence suggesting that Earth may have had a ring system that formed around 466 million years ago, at the beginning of a period of unusually intense meteorite bombardment known as the Ordovician impact spike."

    My note. As more and more astronomical studies take place involving impacts in the solar system, Charles Darwin warm little pond in 1871 needs much modification now for violent catastrophism, including long ages for evolution to take place, more violence, more mass extinction, and death. Looks like violent impacts and catastrophism must be extended well beyond 4 billion years ago now. Apophis fits into this paradigm and extending catastrophism into the present, perhaps :)
    Reply
  • izraulhidashi
    absorbingphotons said:
    At best, this article is clickbait. At its worst, this article is bad journalism.

    Writing a headline like that when you know well that NASA has already stated there is 0% chance of Apophis hitting Earth for the next 100 years. You all should be ashamed of yourselves...

    Stop sensationalizing Apophis just for clicks & ad revenue. Greed on its finest display.
    And you expect NASA would tell the truth? LOL Super brilliant!
    Reply
  • Pogo
    NASA is not the only source of information. There are many universities and other groups who would communicate information like this. They would keep NASA on the up and up. That’s one reason to doubt the Apollo nay-sayers. If Apollo was faked, the Soviet Union and others would have jumped right on it with proof. NASA and related sites are pretty good sources as they are a lot of information in one location.
    Reply